It looks like Twenty-Fourteen may be the ticket for the site. It’s not perfect; I can’t put up a proper header image as the height is far too small to get the image I want. But thanks to Darrell Dow at Stuff Fundies Like, I snagged a plugin that allowed me to change the colors of the home page. I’m also researching various plugins that will allow me to change the fonts if I so choose. I’m having trouble snagging a Google fonts API–I’m just not sure how to do it, even with the instructions that one of the plugins gives. Still, it’s a start.